Joseph Lathrop Allen’s Life and Career

Any history project suffers from missing data, many facts are not in the record. Of course, much is yet to be found, not digitized and not combed through by the right enthusiast, or yet put into the right context. For the earliest musical instrument makers, we will we rely on surviving instruments. The instruments that they made in the early years were soon considered out of date and all but a few were discarded. We have little data to rely on to know the size of their production and examples of many instruments mentioned in the historic record are not among the survivors and, of course, the unknown unknowns. Dr. Robert Eliason published an excellent article on J. L. Allen in 1979, part of his “Early American Brass Makers”, and only a small bit can be added to that record. The following is an attempt to add what has been learned, including later research that was given to the author by Eliason. And, as always, my speculation about what is missing.

Joseph Lathrop Allen was born in Holland, Massachusetts on September 24, 1815 to Captain (also known as “Colonel”) Ezra Allen and Lucena Fuller Allen. J.L. moved to nearby Sturbridge in about 1838 and married Phebe S. Partridge on May 7, 1839. We don’t know where he learned to make musical instruments, but later in life he stated that he became a jeweler and played in a band in Worcester. The leader of a visiting band proposed a partnership to build musical instruments there. No other sources have been found indicating that he had lived or worked in Worcester, but in that same interview, he mentioned that he moved the shop several times before ending up in Boston. We can allow for faulty memory late in life, but the thought of Allen in Worcester, where Isaac Fiske made brass instruments by 1842, is worthy of further research. Sturbridge was under 30 miles from Worcester and about 60 miles from both Winchester, New Hampshire, where James Keat and Graves & Company were making brass instruments and Boston, where Henry Sibley and E.G. Wright worked.

Photos above and at head of article Courtesy of Old Sturbridge Village

Only one instrument is known that was made by Allen in Sturbridge, an Eb keyed bugle of copper and brass with nine keys. It is very similar in design to those made by Henry Sibley, Graves & Co., Isaac Fiske and E. G. Wright. Fortunately, it is preserved in the collection of Old Sturbridge Village with mouthpiece and shank that are likely original. The author has not examined this instrument in hand, but it appears to be of high quality construction.

Allen moved to Boston by 1842 and the only instrument known from that time is a Bb post horn with three double piston valves, again very similar to those by contemporary New England makers. Eliason reported an advertisement from The American Journal of Music and Musical Visitor by music store owner and publisher B. A. Burditt in 1844. It lists valve post horns, valve trumpets, trombones, ophiclydes (sic) and bugles, all made by Allen.

Allen moved to Norwich, Connecticut in 1844 and formed a partnership with Lewis Raymond and rented rooms from him in his house. Their shop was initially on Allen Street and then at 2 Chapman’s Block, Franklin Square. Little is known of Raymond other than that he was born in Ashby, Massachusetts on December 15, 1816, and his father was a wagon maker there. He died just months after getting married in 1846. In order to purchase Raymond’s portion of the business, Allen had to mortgage his tools and equipment to Boston publisher and music store owner, George P. Reed. Eliason published inventory of the mortgaged items without values. Raymond’s probate included an inventory of the entire partnership of Allen and Raymond, and because the descriptive terms used were mostly the same, the values can be assigned to the inventory that Allen had mortgaged with some accuracy. It looks like a shorter list at first, but the value is very close to half of the entire inventory, $254, compared to the total of $481.72. This indicates that the partnership was very likely in equal parts. The inventory also indicates that the shop was well equipped for manufacturing most, if not all of the parts that were required to make brass instruments including at least six bell mandrels. The lathe, even accounting for the inclusion of the drive wheel, pulleys etc. worth $65 must have been a fairly modern piece of machinery.

From this shop, two instruments are known to survive, a post horn in Bb and a tenor or baritone in C and with slides for Bb (pictured below). Both of these instruments are copper and brass and have double piston valves with what we now call “Mainzer” mechanism. Named for the city of origin, it involves long lever with leaf springs and push rods acting directly on the piston assemblies. The markings on neither of these include Raymond’s name. The post horn is very similar to Allen’s earlier example, but with one key about five inches from the bell rim. Engraved on the bell garland is “J. Lathrop Allen Norwich Ct.” The tenor or baritone is engraved on the bell “Allen & Co., Norwich, Conn.”. It is made of Copper and brass with three double piston valves, in the same form as trombacellos made by Graves & Co., but more modern proportions and larger bore.

Among the finished and unfinished parts listed in the probate inventory were valves, crooks, slide tubes, 3 bugle bells, 3 unfinished bugle bells and “1 doz. unfinished bell instruments”. Finished instruments listed were one each ophicleide in B and Eb, two trombones and one “Tuba”. The instrument name “tuba” was not normally seen in advertising and price lists of American makers in the second half of the 19th century, but was used for describing instruments made by Thomas Paine in Woonsocket, Rhode Island and E.G. Wright, Boston in 1845, and later in H. B. Dodworth’s list of instruments for sale in New York, 1856. In the latter, it is clear by the context that they were the large bass instruments: basses in Bb and Ab and contrabasses in Eb and CC, all with rotary valves, and were most likely made in New England by Allen, Graves, Wright or Fiske. The only context for the 1845 tubas is what little we actually know about larger valve brass instruments made in the US at that time. These include tenor and bass trombacellos, mostly by Graves & Co., and a surviving German style tuba in F, also copper and brass, with five Berliner piston valves, also made by Graves & Co. in Winchester, New Hampshire. Starting in the late 1830s the Germanic term “bass-tuba”, described contrabass instruments in F, very much like the instrument by Graves. The author sees a likelihood that the tubas of Wright, Paine and Allen were baritone/bass and contrabass instruments with double piston valves and/or Berliner piston valves. They may have been similar to this baritone instrument by Allen that appears to be a trombacello until one looks more closely.

Allen made a success on his own after recovering from the loss of his partner. Starting sometime before the census of 1850, Louis Ferdinand Hartmann, a brass instrument maker from Markneukirchen, Saxony was living with him. Markneukirchen was Europe’s center for musical instrument making and Hartmann’s father was a member of the instrument maker’s guild there. According to Eliason, he first arrived in the US with his family in 1839 when he was 12 years old. A few years later, he returned to Markneukirchen, presumably to learn more of the brass instrument making trade. He returned in August, 1848, listed in the ships log as “Instrumentmaker”. When Allen moved back to Boston in 1852, Hartmann continued to be part of the household including at the time of the 1855 state census, but no longer in 1860. The shop address in 1852 was 19 Harvard Place, in 1853 it was 17 Harvard Place and then 1857 through 1860 at 18 Harvard Place. The latter address was also used by Graves and Wright before and after and begs the speculation that this group of makers were pooling resources, exchanging parts, assemblies and labor during the 1850s. Additional evidence is seen in three Eb contrabasses with bells over the shoulder. The earliest is marked marked “Allen & Hall, 334 Wash. St., Boston” in the Henry Ford Museum and the latest “J. L. ALLEN, N.Y., MAKER” (illustrated later in this article). All of these instruments appear to be made of the same parts as as those by Graves and Wright between the late 1850s and 1870 and later by the Boston Musical Instrument Manufactory. The two earlier Allen instruments have “Allen” valves and the later has valves of the design used by Wright and Boston.

It was about 1850 that Allen designed his unique flat windway rotary valves with short and very rapid action. Today these are known as “Allen valves”. Hartmann’s instrument making experience likely enabled the shop to efficiently produce these valves. Based on surviving instruments, all of Allen’s instruments after 1850 utilized this valve design until he moved from Boston. It is likely that Allen was also the designer of the side action valve levers seen on the baritone pictured above in the mid-1850s. After about 1860, this design was copied by E. G. Wright, Graves & Co. and Isaac Fiske. It was very popular on American instruments through the 1860s and 1870s, most made in Germany for the US market.

In 1852, Allen was briefly in partnership with Benjamin Franklin Richardson, who continued making brass instruments in his own shop later. More importantly, Allen hired more German trained makers in subsequent years. The following may be a bit confusing and is subject to new data. The New England brass instrument manufacturing scene is a puzzle that the author is attempting to assemble with many pieces missing. We can only view from afar the characters involved, moving from shop to shop, knowing that we will never know the whole story. The German makers included Franz Huttl, who arrived in New York on April 7, 1854. His brothers Ferdinand, Anton and Erhardt and Joseph Koestler, arrived together the ship “Nelson Sworn” on June 29, 1854, along with four others that aren’t known to have worked for Allen. All eight of these men were listed as “Instrumentmaker” and about 15 others, wives, children and servants, were travelling with them. Koestler was also a die sinker and would have been the one that made the stamps and dies for the name shields seen on Allen’s instruments in the 1850s as well as those for Wright, Graves and others in Boston. Also working with them was August Doelling, who had arrived on June 1, 1854. Franz Huttl went on to a life of farming, but the other five makers worked at Allen’s shop at 18 Harvard Place at least by 1858 when they were listed in the city directory, and likely the previous years.

Another German from Saxony, Henry Esbach, arrived in 1847 as a “mechanic” and went to work for E. G. Wright for the next ten years. He had travelled back to Germany and returned on September 4, 1850, listed as “instrumentmacher”. He was working in Allen’s workshop in 1858. By 1858, the business name was “Allen Manufacturing Company”, having previously engraved his instruments “J. Lathrop Allen, Maker”, “Manufactured by J. Lathrop Allen” or simply “Allen & Co.”.

The earliest price list for Allen’s instrument found so far was published by Higgins Bros., a music store in Chicago. This appeared in the Chicago Tribune on August 15, 1858. Not surprisingly, it only offers instruments with rotary valves. Cornets could be ordered in pure silver and pure gold. A set of 21 instruments of solid coin silver were ordered by L. H. Wright for the St. Louis Silver Cornet Band, plus one solid gold cornet at the total cost of $5500. This is the equivalent of roughly $225,000 in 2026. Later advertising for “Wright & Kost’s Coin Silver Band” were taken out in St. Louis papers.

In 1861, Allen moved to 334 Washington Street and entered a partnership with the famous keyed bugle soloist David Culver Hall. Towards the end of his life, at the age of 90 years, Allen stated that at the start of the Civil War in 1861, he had 24 employees. If true, he was one of the largest maker of brass instruments in the country. Eliason reported that none of the German makers followed him to that shop. However, they hired the twin brothers Benjamin Franklin and George Washington Quinby, who were well established machinists at the time. It’s possible that the Quinbys were already making parts and/or tools for Allen, Wright, Graves and other. Starting in 1862, they must have accomplished much of the work in the shop. They were joined by another brother John Oliver Quinby and eventually BF’s son George F Quinby, who was an accomplished machinist himself. Other workers in the shop must have included both those that they trained and, likely, other German trained makers. Of the four other instrument makers that arrived on the Nelson Sworn in 1854, Vinzenz Joseph was listed in a Boston directory in 1865 as “Inst. Maker” and Emanuel Riedl was listed that way until 1908 and then as retired in 1910. No sources have been found listing where they worked, in spite of a Riedl descendent spending many hours searching genealogical records.

In 1861, Allen left and was settled in a new shop at 111 East 18th Street in New York City before the end of the year. D. C. Hall continued in Boston, thereafter heading the business under his own name. The Quinby Brothers and others were making the instruments for him, and in 1866 the business name changed to Hall & Quinby. This branch of the story will be continued on its own page in the future.

One of the first instruments that Allen completed in New York was a solid silver Eb cornet with Allen valves. In his 1979 Early American Brass Makers, Dr. Robert Eliason estimated this instrument to have been made in about 1870 although we now know that it is the silver cornet that was reported in newspaper articles as given to George R. Choate by the officers of New York’s 35th Regiment in December of 1861. The address engraved on the bell garland is not among those listed in the New York City directories. Allen occupied that address, at 111 East 18th Street, for a short time in 1861 and moved before the 1862 directory was compiled. It was roughly four blocks from where his home was listed in 1862 and 1863, between Union Square and Gramercy Park. The home address, 180 E. 21st Street, is the same as for Harvey Dodworth, indicating a continued relationship with him.

Interestingly, the valves on this instrument are a slight variation of those made in the Allen, Hall and Quinby shops in Boston. The internal stop design is the same, but they are larger diameter, shorter in length and the shape of the flattened windways is slightly different. In the second photo below, you can see the slight differences in the shape and proportions of the valve casings and ports. The difference is better seen in the last group of photos, which has two views each of rotors from instruments by Allen, New York, D.C. Hall (about 1864), Henry Lehnert (about 1870) and B.F. Richardson (1854). A number of instruments with Allen style valves, mostly unsigned appear to be German made for the US market or had parts made there. We must also consider that Allen was having parts made in German shops that were more firmly established in the industry. Of course, it is also possible that Allen did make these parts in his New York shop without parts purchased from his Boston associates or from overseas. After all, he had been making brass instruments for over 20 years, including his uniquely designed rotary valves for the previous 10 years or more.

He continued to be listed as a musical instrument maker in New York until 1869, although only four instruments are known from this era. The others are a Bb cornet with four standard rotary valves with side action levers, an Eb tuba with bell over the shoulder, also with standard rotary valves, and a French horn with Berliner valves in the New York Metropolitan Museum of Art. The latter appears to be of German design and make, but Allen may have assembled it or modified it in some way. As discussed above, the tuba appears to be the same as those made by E.G. Wright & Co. The valves and levers on Allen’s tuba that he made in New York, appear the same as those on Wright’s instruments, unlike those made by the Allen, Hall and Quinby shops in Boston.

The city directory indicates that his shop moved almost every year: 224 Broome in 1862, 250 Canal in 1863, 62 Centre in 1864, 211 Grand from 1865 through 1867, then 6 Astor Place in 1868. While there is no evidence that he had filed for a patent on his unique rotary valve design in the early 1850s, he did receive a patent for a paper cutting shear in 1868.

The Bb cornet made by Allen in New York has rotary valves very similar in design to those used by other New York makers such as Moennig and Stark. These valve assemblies appear the same as in instruments imported from Germany, but is is also possible that there was a valve maker in New York. This cornet also features valve lever and brace designs inspired by those of Isaac Fiske, which Moennig and Stark also emulated.

The 1870 census listed Allen as an electrician and in subsequent years his occupation was Alarms, Superintendent, Agricultural implements, Machinist, Inspector and finally Stereopticons in 1897. He was 82 by then and his list of occupations indicate that he was not one to retire.

Phebe died in 1892, but J. L. soldiered on by himself. Previous census records never showed any children living with the Allens. He kept busy, evidenced not only by his many occupations, but also an article published near the end of his life by the Boston Globe On November 15, 1905. While visiting Boston, at the age of 90, he was interviewed for this article. This included the only image of the man that the author knows of. He mentioned his relationship with Boston publisher and music store owner, George P. Reed in a very positive light for respecting his high level of workmanship. It was Reed to whom he mortgaged all his tools in 1846 in order to purchase his deceased partners half of their business. He expressed disdain for the importers of cheap German instruments in New York and mentions William A. Pond & Co., who he must have had some dealings with.

In the state census taken 1905, he was listed as “inmate” in the Chapin House on East 66th Street. In spite of the name used by the census takers for residents, it was a fairly upscale home for elderly and infirm. About 84% of its residents were women, all over 65. Joseph Lathrop Allen died at 91 on September 24, 1906.